Refinishing vs. Resurfacing Hardwood: Which Method Do You Need?
When your hardwood floors lose their luster, you’ll hear two terms thrown around: “refinishing” and “resurfacing.” While they sound similar, they are very different processes.
For homeowners in Vestavia Hills, Mountain Brook, Hoover, Homewood, and Greystone, choosing the wrong one can mean either overspending on a project you didn’t need or failing to fix the damage you actually have.
What is Resurfacing? (The “Buff and Coat”)
Resurfacing—often called a “screen and recoat”—is a maintenance procedure.
The Process: We lightly scuff the existing finish with a buffer (screening) and then apply a fresh topcoat of polyurethane.
When to use it: Use this when your floor is just “dull” but doesn’t have deep scratches or bare wood showing. It’s a great way to “freshen up” a home in Vestavia Hills before listing it for sale.
What is Refinishing? (The Deep Dive)
Refinishing is a complete overhaul of the floor.
The Process: We use heavy machinery to sand the floor down to the raw, bare wood. This removes the old finish, deep scratches, and stains. We then apply stain (if you want to change the color) and multiple protective topcoats.
The Benefit: This allows you to completely change the look of your home—turning a 90s “honey oak” floor into a modern, matte “white oak” look.
Comparing Costs and Timelines
| Feature | Resurfacing (Screen & Recoat) | Full Refinishing |
| Time | 1 Day | 3–5 Days |
| Mess | Minimal | Significant (Dust) |
| Price | Affordable ($) | Investment ($$$) |
| Result | Restores Shine | Restores Wood Integrity |
Making the Right Choice for Your Space
If you can see the grain of the wood through the scratches, or if the color of the wood has changed, resurfacing won’t help. You need the deep sand of a refinish. However, if your floors just look “tired” but are structurally sound, resurfacing can save you thousands.
Contact In and Out Flooring Today!
Whether you need a light buff or a deep sand, In and Out Flooring delivers the “impeccable craftsmanship” Birmingham expects. We handle the dust, the detail, and the design.
Unsure which method your floors need? Schedule an in-home visit with our specialists to get an expert’s opinion.
Our Service Areas; Vestavia Hills, Mountain Brook, Hoover, Homewood, and Greystone