When Should I Refinish My Hardwood? Signs Your Floors Need Love
Hardwood floors are a staple of Birmingham architecture, from the historic cottages in Homewood to the stately homes in Mountain Brook.
However, even the toughest oak or hickory floors eventually show their age. Refinishing is the “reset button” for your flooring, but timing is everything. Wait too long, and you might face expensive board replacements; act too early, and you’re sanding away precious wood unnecessarily.
At In and Out Flooring, we help you identify the perfect window for restoration.
The Water Drop Test: A Quick Health Check
The most critical job of your floor’s finish is to keep moisture out of the wood. In a humid climate like Birmingham’s, a compromised finish can lead to rot or warping.
The Test: Place a few drops of water on a high-traffic area of your floor.
The Result: If the water beads up, your finish is still doing its job. If it soaks in immediately and leaves a dark spot, your protective seal is gone. This is a definitive sign that it’s time to refinish before the Alabama humidity causes deeper damage.
Visible Wear: Scratches, Dents, and Graying
Daily life in Hoover and Vestavia Hills—pets, kids, and high heels—eventually leaves its mark.
The Gray Effect: When wood starts to turn gray, it means the wood fibers are being exposed to dirt and moisture. This is the “danger zone.”
Surface Scratches: If you see widespread “micro-scratches” that make the floor look dull regardless of how much you clean it, the topcoat has worn down.
Fading from the Alabama Sun
Our beautiful Southern sun is a double-edged sword. UV rays can “bleach” hardwood, especially in rooms with large windows. If you move a rug and see a distinct “tan line” where the floor used to be darker, refinishing can even out the tone and restore the vibrant, original color of your wood.
Structural Red Flags: When Refinishing Isn’t Enough
Refinishing treats the surface. It will not fix structural issues like deep “cupping” (edges higher than the center) or “crowning.” If your boards are buckling or have gaps wide enough to fit a coin, you may need a repair or replacement rather than just a sand and finish.
Bring the Showroom to Your Living Room
Refinishing is a big decision, but it’s the best way to protect your investment. At In and Out Flooring, we bring the expertise to you. We can assess your floors right in your home and provide a clear plan for restoration.
Think your floors are ready for a refresh? Contact In and Out Flooring today for a free in-home evaluation in Birmingham!
Our Service Areas: Vestavia Hills, Mountain Brook, Hoover, Homewood, and Greystone

